The first worker changes the books more than the second one does. Set up the records before the first payment, and the year-end forms and questions are much easier.

First, describe the work

Write down what the person will do, who decides how and when it's done, who supplies the tools, how they're paid and whether the work is ongoing. Classification follows those facts, not the label on the agreement.

  • Federal: the IRS looks at three categories of evidence: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. See Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee? (opens in a new tab)
  • New Jersey: under its unemployment compensation law, New Jersey applies the ABC test. A worker is an employee unless all three conditions are met: the worker is free from control or direction over the work; the work is outside the usual course of the business, or outside all of its places of business; and the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established business. See the NJ Department of Labor's guidance (opens in a new tab).

The two tests can reach different answers for the same worker. This checklist gives no classification conclusion.

Records for a contractor

  • A signed agreement that describes the work
  • The applicable contractor tax form, collected through a secure channel before the first payment: Form W-9 for a U.S. person, or the appropriate Form W-8 or Form 8233 for a foreign person; confirm the payee and applicable form
  • Invoices, and a payment history by contractor
  • How each payment was made. Covered credit-card and third-party-network payments follow the payment settlement entity's Form 1099-K rules rather than the payer's Form 1099-NEC rules; issuer-specific thresholds and exceptions can mean no form is furnished (IRS instructions (opens in a new tab)).

Records for an employee

An employee means payroll. Payroll setup and operation are considered case by case under a separate written engagement and may be referred to an independent specialist. For the books, keep the payroll provider's report for each pay period and its year-end totals; the provider will tell you which forms it needs from the employee.

Who keeps what

  • Who collects the applicable contractor tax form or the payroll provider's forms, and where they're stored (not in email)
  • Who records each payment in the books
  • Who prepares the year-end information returns for contractors, and who files New Jersey's required new-hire report for each new contractor or employee (generally within 20 days)

What happens next

Describe the work you're hiring for through the contact form. Never put a worker's identification number in the inquiry.